Torn ACL: symptoms, diagnosis and when surgery is needed
The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) keeps the knee stable when we twist, stop or jump. It often tears in soccer, basketball and skiing, and also in falls. Not every tear needs surgery: the decision depends on your age, your activity level, whether the knee gives way and whether there are other injuries, such as a meniscus tear.
How does the ACL tear?
Most of the time it happens without a direct blow: twisting with the foot planted, changing direction suddenly or landing badly from a jump. It can also tear in an accident or from a blow to the knee.
Most common symptoms
- A pop or a feeling that something tore at the moment of injury.
- Swelling of the knee within the first hours.
- Pain and difficulty putting weight on the leg at first.
- Later, a feeling that the knee gives way, especially when pivoting or going down stairs.
If your knee swelled a lot after a twist or a fall, it should be checked by an orthopedic surgeon soon, even if the pain has eased.
How is it diagnosed?
The doctor examines the knee with tests that measure its stability and, in most cases, orders an MRI. The MRI confirms the tear and shows associated injuries, such as meniscus or cartilage damage, that change the treatment.
Is surgery always needed?
No. Each case is evaluated:
- Non-surgical treatment: physical therapy and strengthening. It may be an option for people with low sports activity and no feeling of instability.
- ACL reconstruction: usually recommended for young or active people, those who play pivoting sports, when the knee gives way in daily life, or when there is a meniscus tear worth repairing.
A knee that keeps giving way can damage the meniscus and cartilage over time. That is why it is not a good idea to live with the instability without an evaluation.
What is the surgery like?
Reconstruction is done by arthroscopy, through small incisions: the torn ligament is replaced with a graft, usually a tendon from the patient. Meniscus injuries can be treated in the same procedure. Read more in our article on knee arthroscopy.
How long is the recovery?
- First weeks: crutches, swelling control and regaining motion.
- First months: progressive strengthening with the physical therapist.
- Return to sports: generally not before about 9 months, and only when strength and functional tests allow it. Studies show that returning earlier increases the risk of a new injury.
Questions to ask at your visit
- Does my knee need surgery, or can I try physical therapy?
- Do I also have a meniscus or cartilage injury?
- Which graft would be used in my case?
- If I'm traveling from abroad, how long should I stay in Quito after surgery?
Book your evaluation
Dr. Germán Salazar Argüello sees patients at Hospital AXXIS, 3rd floor, and on Thursday afternoons at Novaclínica Santa Cecilia, office 211, Quito. Dr. Mathías Salazar speaks fluent English.
Book: +593 98 829 9704🎁 Free guide: text us “GUIDE” on WhatsApp and we'll send you our guide to prepare for your visit (in Spanish).
This content is for information only and does not replace a medical evaluation. Timelines and costs vary from patient to patient. See more articles